Tata Motors recently unveiled a brand-new TV commercial for the upcoming Tata Sierra, one of the most iconic names in the company’s SUV history. While the TVC received mass attention for its nostalgic tone, rugged visuals, and premium outdoor vibe, it also sparked a heated debate online. Many viewers claim that the Sierra TVC looks surprisingly similar to Ford’s famous Bronco commercial.
This has raised an important question: Did Tata Motors actually copy Ford? Or is the similarity just a coincidence rooted in common industry trends?
In this 1000-word deep dive, we break down the controversy, compare the visuals, explore industry practices, and understand what this means for both Tata Motors and the Sierra brand.
The TVC That Triggered the Debate
The new Tata Sierra TVC focuses on:
- A rugged mountain setting
- An emotional voice-over
- A couple reconnecting with nature
- The SUV showcased in wide, scenic shots
- A focus on adventure and nostalgia
While the visuals are stunning, social media users were quick to point out that the camera angles, storytelling style, and frame compositions look very similar to Ford Bronco’s iconic advertisement.
This led to strong reactions online, with some alleging plagiarism and others defending the ad as creative inspiration.
What People Are Comparing: Sierra vs. Ford Bronco TVCs
Here are the key similarities being discussed:
1. The Adventure-Based Narrative
Both advertisements revolve around:
- Escaping the city
- Driving into nature
- Reconnecting with freedom
This thematic approach is extremely common for SUVs, but the style of execution is what people are comparing.
2. Cinematic Shot Composition
Users noted similarities such as:
- Drone shots of the SUV cutting through a valley
- Side-profile slow-motion tracking shots
- A final silhouette shot during sunset
These angles do resemble typical Ford Bronco visuals, especially from the 2020 relaunch campaign.
3. The Nostalgia Element
The Bronco ad built on the SUV’s heritage, and the TVC for the Sierra uses a similar emotional narrative tied to legacy.
4. The Same “Wilderness + Lone SUV + Emotional Voice” Formula
This is a familiar pattern in global SUV commercials, yet the resemblance feels closer than coincidence for some viewers.
Are These Similarities Enough to Call It a Copy?
While similarities exist, calling it a copy may oversimplify a complex creative process.
1. SUV Advertisements Often Look Alike
Outdoor locations, drone shots, and rugged terrains are standard templates for showcasing SUVs. Brands from Toyota, Jeep, Land Rover, Nissan, and Ford have all used similar storytelling.
2. The Sierra Has Its Own Identity
- The Sierra TVC focuses heavily on nostalgia and Indian emotion
- The narrative is softer and more relationship-driven
- The Bronco TVC focuses more on power, heritage, and toughness
The emotional tone differs significantly.
3. Inspiration ≠ Copying
Creative industries often borrow:
- Visual tones
- Color palettes
- Storytelling structures
Unless the visuals are frame-by-frame identical, it’s not considered plagiarism.
4. Many Brands Follow Global Trends
The “adventure lifestyle SUV” aesthetic is a trending global marketing style.
Tata’s ad fits into that broader theme rather than appearing as a direct imitation.
Public Reaction: Divided Opinions Online
The reactions have been mixed:
✔ Supporters Say:
- The ad looks premium and world-class
- It elevates the Sierra brand
- It follows global SUV commercial traditions
- Comparisons are exaggerated
✘ Critics Say:
- The ad lacks originality
- Some scenes look too similar to Ford Bronco visuals
- Tata should build a more unique creative identity
- India’s growing automobile market deserves fresh concepts
The debate continues, but one thing is clear: the TVC has captured massive attention, which, ironically, may benefit the brand.
Why the Sierra TVC Matters So Much
The Sierra isn’t just any SUV. It is a revival of an Indian automotive legend. The original Tata Sierra was one of India’s first lifestyle SUVs, and its comeback holds emotional value for many enthusiasts.
This TVC was expected to re-establish:
- The SUV’s adventurous character
- Its premium and modern upgrade
- Its nostalgic connection with the 1990s generation
Any controversy surrounding the commercial naturally becomes a bigger deal because the Sierra has such strong emotional value.
Could This Controversy Impact the Sierra Launch?
Unlikely.
In fact, the buzz may help the brand.
Why It May Help:
- Free publicity
- Social media attention
- Curiosity about the SUV
- Increased brand recall
Why It Won’t Hurt Much:
- TVC controversies rarely affect sales
- Most customers care more about specs & price than ads
- Tata is known for strong brand loyalty
- The Sierra already has high anticipation
So, whether inspired or original, the campaign has people talking—and that’s valuable.
The Bigger Picture: Is Originality in Advertising Dying?
Today, global advertising follows trends:
- Adventure storytelling
- Minimal dialogue
- Emotional cinematography
- Wide-angle drone shots
Brands often use similar aesthetics because they work.
Consumers connect with these themes and continue to demand them.
So the question isn’t “Did Tata copy Ford?” but rather:
Is the SUV advertising world becoming too uniform?
This controversy opens up an interesting conversation on creativity in advertising and how brands should differentiate themselves in a crowded market.
Final Verdict: Copy or Coincidence?
After examining all angles, here’s the fair conclusion:
- Yes, some visual similarities exist.
- No, it cannot be called a direct copy.
- Yes, both ads follow a common global trend.
- No, the core storytelling and emotion differ.
The Tata Sierra TVC appears inspired by global SUV advertising styles, including the Ford Bronco, but not copied outright. The ad still manages to give the Sierra its own emotional and nostalgic identity.
At the end of the day, viewers are talking about the Sierra more than ever—and that might be exactly what Tata Motors wanted.
About the Author
